Data / Holiday 2026
We asked AI assistants 100 holiday gift questions. Here is who they named, and where they looked.
300 answers from Claude, each question asked 3 times, on 2026-11-19. Measured through the official APIs with web search, like the free Shopworthy check.
Pilot. This edition covers Claude only. ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity are being added; numbers may change when they are.
What we found
- Gift answers cite gift guides far more than anything else: 78% of cited pages were gift guides and "best of" articles on sites other than big publishers, many of them small stores' own blogs. Big publishers made up 13%, retailers and marketplaces 2%, and brands' and stores' product pages 7%.
- Ask the same gift question again and you get a different list: the brands named overlapped by 60% on average between repeats, and the first brand named was the same only 51% of the time.
- Answers named Amazon in 7% of cases and any big retailer or marketplace in 17%; Etsy came up in 5%.
- The most-named brand overall was Quince, in 6% of answers. Each answer named 2.5 brands on average.
Where the answers got their picks
Every page the answers cited, 1,250 in all.
"Gift guides on other sites" are pages titled like a guide or list ("best gifts for coffee lovers"), or on a blog, that are not on a big publisher's site. Many belong to small stores and roasters.
For store owners: a clear, honest gift guide on your own site is the kind of page these answers cite. How assistants pick products.
Most-named brands
Share of all answers naming each brand.
By category
Share of that category's answers naming each brand.
Coffee 21 answers
Tea 21 answers
Candles 21 answers
Skincare 21 answers
Jewelry 21 answers
Clothing 21 answers
Outdoor gear 21 answers
Kitchen 21 answers
Home decor 21 answers
Stationery 21 answers
Toys and games 21 answers
Pets 21 answers
Chocolate and sweets 21 answers
Bags and wallets 21 answers
General gift questions 6 answers
By assistant
| Assistant | Answers | Same brands on repeat | Same first pick | Names Amazon | Most named |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Claude | 300 | 60% | 51% | 7% | Quince, Atlas Coffee Club, Le Creuset |
How we measured
- 100 gift questions written the way shoppers ask, across 15 categories, with no brand in any question. Each asked 3 times per assistant.
- Asked through each assistant's official API with web search on (claude: claude-haiku-5-5). US English, no account history or personalization. Consumer apps can answer differently.
- Brands are the names each answer highlights or lists, counted once per answer wherever they appear in it; product names are merged into their brand where the brand also appears ("AeroPress Original" counts as AeroPress). Big retailers and marketplaces are counted separately.
- Shares are of answers, not rankings: AI lists change between repeats, so how often a brand appears says more than its position.
- Cited pages are those the answer cites, not every page its search returned.
- Questions, the analysis code and the per-category data are public: CSV, JSON. Cost of this run: $8.8 in API fees.