Shopworthy

Data / Holiday 2026

We asked AI assistants 100 holiday gift questions. Here is who they named, and where they looked.

300 answers from Claude, each question asked 3 times, on 2026-11-19. Measured through the official APIs with web search, like the free Shopworthy check.

Pilot. This edition covers Claude only. ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity are being added; numbers may change when they are.

Download the data (CSV)How we measured

What we found

  1. Gift answers cite gift guides far more than anything else: 78% of cited pages were gift guides and "best of" articles on sites other than big publishers, many of them small stores' own blogs. Big publishers made up 13%, retailers and marketplaces 2%, and brands' and stores' product pages 7%.
  2. Ask the same gift question again and you get a different list: the brands named overlapped by 60% on average between repeats, and the first brand named was the same only 51% of the time.
  3. Answers named Amazon in 7% of cases and any big retailer or marketplace in 17%; Etsy came up in 5%.
  4. The most-named brand overall was Quince, in 6% of answers. Each answer named 2.5 brands on average.

Where the answers got their picks

Every page the answers cited, 1,250 in all.

  1. Gift guides on other sites78%
  2. Big publishers and review sites13%
  3. Retailers and marketplaces2%
  4. Brand and store product pages7%

"Gift guides on other sites" are pages titled like a guide or list ("best gifts for coffee lovers"), or on a blog, that are not on a big publisher's site. Many belong to small stores and roasters.

For store owners: a clear, honest gift guide on your own site is the kind of page these answers cite. How assistants pick products.

Most-named brands

Share of all answers naming each brand.

  1. Quince6%
  2. Atlas Coffee Club5%
  3. Le Creuset5%
  4. Black Diamond4%
  5. Darn Tough3%
  6. Nest3%
  7. Harry's3%
  8. Bodum3%
  9. Godiva3%
  10. BYOMA2%
  11. Garmin2%
  12. Lindt2%

By category

Share of that category's answers naming each brand.

Coffee 21 answers

  1. Atlas Coffee Club76%
  2. Bodum29%
  3. Fellow Stagg EKG29%
  4. Hario V6024%
  5. Trade Coffee24%
  6. Chemex19%

Tea 21 answers

  1. Pukka29%
  2. Tea Forte29%
  3. Twinings29%
  4. Yogi29%
  5. Plum Deluxe19%
  6. Atlas Tea Club14%

Candles 21 answers

  1. Nest43%
  2. Voluspa33%
  3. Diptyque29%
  4. Thymes Frasier Fir29%
  5. Trudon24%
  6. Fontana19%

Skincare 21 answers

  1. BYOMA33%
  2. Tatcha29%
  3. Summer Fridays19%
  4. Abib Gummy Sheet Mask14%
  5. Harry's14%
  6. Hydrinity14%

Jewelry 21 answers

  1. HerMJ14%
  2. EcoDunia10%
  3. Made By Hand Online10%
  4. Gabriel & Co5%
  5. MakerPlace5%

Clothing 21 answers

  1. Quince48%
  2. Patagonia24%
  3. Everlane14%
  4. Girlfriend Collective14%
  5. Mott & Bow14%
  6. Naadam14%

Outdoor gear 21 answers

  1. Black Diamond52%
  2. Darn Tough48%
  3. Garmin33%
  4. Injinji24%
  5. AllTrails+14%
  6. Katadyn BeFree14%

Kitchen 21 answers

  1. Le Creuset62%
  2. Lodge33%
  3. All-Clad D314%
  4. Calphalon Premier14%
  5. Made In14%
  6. Mercer Millennia14%

Home decor 21 answers

  1. Barefoot Dreams CozyChic14%
  2. Bedsure GentleSoft14%
  3. Pom Pom Sherpa Throw14%
  4. UGG Bliss Throw14%
  5. Warmies14%
  6. Diaspora Co. Chai Masala10%

Stationery 21 answers

  1. Moleskine24%
  2. Hobonichi Techo10%
  3. Pilot Vanishing Point10%
  4. TWSBI Diamond10%
  5. Wordsworth & Black Crest10%
  6. Blotter5%

Toys and games 21 answers

  1. Flip24%
  2. Snap Circuits24%
  3. Botley14%
  4. Cascadia14%
  5. Hot Dots14%
  6. LEGO Technic14%

Pets 21 answers

  1. KONG24%
  2. Casper Dog Bed14%
  3. Catstages Tower of Tracks14%
  4. Frisco14%
  5. Contender Bones10%
  6. Purina Gentle Snackers10%

Chocolate and sweets 21 answers

  1. Godiva38%
  2. Lindt33%
  3. Hotel Chocolat29%
  4. La Maison29%
  5. Ethel M19%
  6. Ferrero14%

Bags and wallets 21 answers

  1. Ekster Cardholder Pro14%
  2. Herschel Little America14%
  3. JanSport Big Student14%
  4. Maya Midi14%
  5. Quince Italian Leather Quilted Crossbody14%
  6. Ridge Wallet14%

General gift questions 6 answers

  1. Harry & David50%
  2. Le Creuset50%
  3. Facebook Marketplace33%
  4. Instagram Shop33%
  5. TikTok Shop33%
  6. Four Bluetooth17%

By assistant

AssistantAnswersSame brands on repeatSame first pickNames AmazonMost named
Claude30060%51%7%Quince, Atlas Coffee Club, Le Creuset

How we measured

  • 100 gift questions written the way shoppers ask, across 15 categories, with no brand in any question. Each asked 3 times per assistant.
  • Asked through each assistant's official API with web search on (claude: claude-haiku-5-5). US English, no account history or personalization. Consumer apps can answer differently.
  • Brands are the names each answer highlights or lists, counted once per answer wherever they appear in it; product names are merged into their brand where the brand also appears ("AeroPress Original" counts as AeroPress). Big retailers and marketplaces are counted separately.
  • Shares are of answers, not rankings: AI lists change between repeats, so how often a brand appears says more than its position.
  • Cited pages are those the answer cites, not every page its search returned.
  • Questions, the analysis code and the per-category data are public: CSV, JSON. Cost of this run: $8.8 in API fees.

Do AI assistants recommend your store for gifts?

Check my store